Department of Environmental Conservation

D E C banner

Ice Fishing in Cortland County

Popular Ice Fishing Waters in Cortland County
Water Townships Species Regulations Comments Contour Map
Casterline Pond Homer Panfish, Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout Statewide Regulations Apply 9 acres, public access site. Yes
Goodale Lake Preble Panfish, Pickerel 45 acres, shallow, weedy lake. No
Little York Lake Preble, Homer Panfish, Pickerel, Rainbow Trout, Brown Trout 150 acres, deep lake providing a diverse fishery. Yes
Tri-County Pond Harford, Caroline Panfish, Rainbow Trout 1.7 acres, semi-remote pond located at the intersection of Cortland, Tioga and Tompkins County lines. No
Skaneateles Lake Scott Panfish, Pickerel, Lake Trout Finger Lakes and Tributaries Regulations Apply 8,960 acres, ice fishing at the north and south ends Yes
Papish Pond Cincinnatus Panfish, Pickerel Statewide Regulations Apply 19 acres, shallow, weedy lake. No
Tully Lake Preble Panfish, Pickerel 230 acres, shallow, weedy lake. Yes

For information on ice fishing basics and safety, visit our Learn to Ice Fish webpage.

Lake Contour Maps for Cortland County