Department of Environmental Conservation

D E C banner

Ice Fishing in Herkimer County

Popular Ice Fishing Waters in Herkimer County
Water Town Species Regulations Comments
Beardsley Lake Manheim Trout, Yellow Perch, Panfish Special Regulations Beardsley Reservoir Fishing Access Site off Beardsley Road
Hinckley Reservoir Multiple Trout, Yellow Perch, Panfish Special Regulations NY Power Authority Boat Launch off NYS Route 365
Prospect Reservoir Multiple Trout, Yellow Perch, Panfish Special Regulations Prospect Reservoir Boat Launch off NYS Route 365
First Lake Webb Yellow Perch, Tiger Muskellunge Special Regulations Access through chain of lakes
Forestport Res. Forestport Chain Pickerel Statewide Regulations Apply Forestport Rec Fishing Access Site off River Road
Fourth Lake Webb Yellow Perch, Lake Trout, Rainbow Trout, Landlocked Salmon Special Regulations Fourth Lake Day Use Area off Petrie Road; Fourth Lake Fishing Access Site off NYS Route 28
Kayuta Lake Forestport Pickerel, Panfish Statewide Regulations Apply Kayuta Lake Fishing Access Site off State Dam Road
Limekiln Lake Ohio Splake Special Regulations DEC Campground and Day Use Area off Limekiln Road
Moshier Reservoir Webb Tiger Muskellunge, Panfish Statewide Regulations Apply Moshier Reservoir Fishing Access Site off Necessary Dam Road
North Lake Ohio Tiger Muskellunge, Perch Special Regulations North Lake Fishing Access Site off South Lake Road
Old Forge Pond Webb Yellow Perch Special Regulations Municipal Land
Second Lake Webb Yellow Perch Special Regulations Access through chain of lakes
Stillwater Reservoir Webb Splake Special Regulations Stillwater Reservoir Boat Launch Site off Stillwater Road
Third Lake Webb Yellow Perch, Lake Trout, Rainbow Trout Special Regulations Access through chain of lakes
Mohawk River/ Barge Canal Multiple Yellow Perch, Walleye, Panfish Special Regulations Multiple access points
Weaver Lake Warren Panfish Special Regulations Weaver Lake Fishing Access Site off NYS Route 20