NY.gov Portal State Agency Listing Search all of NY.gov
D E C banner
D E C banner

2003 I/M Program Annual Report: Appendix D

Summary of Initial Transient Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data)
County All Vendors (including "Unknown") Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
# of
Facilities		 Total
Volume		 # of
Failed		 % Fail # of
Facilities		 Total
Volume		 # of
Failed		 % Fail # of
Facilities		 Total
Volume		 # of
Failed		 % Fail # of
Facilities		 Total
Volume		 # of
Failed		 % Fail
Bronx 269 258,223 20,598 7.98% 167 168,744 14,050 8.33% 44 36,114 3,482 9.64% 58 53,365 3,066 5.75%
Kings 559 451,021 36,293 8.05% 352 294,748 23,668 8.03% 62 39,827 3,445 8.65% 145 116,446 9,180 7.88%
Nassau 803 614,828 46,794 7.61% 455 350,197 28,827 8.23% 225 180,672 10,902 6.03% 123 83,959 7,065 8.41%
New York 142 100,476 7,944 7.91% 78 52,941 4,193 7.92% 27 26,654 1,630 6.12% 37 20,881 2,121 10.16%
Queens 676 568,822 47,446 8.34% 425 368,000 30,859 8.39% 108 92,188 7,032 7.63% 143 108,634 9,555 8.80%
Richmond 157 141,509 9,793 6.92% 81 79,625 5,068 6.36% 23 17,386 1,169 6.72% 53 44,498 3,556 7.99%
Rockland 133 111,750 8,596 7.69% 87 81,057 6,373 7.86% 27 17,473 1,146 6.56% 19 13,220 1,077 8.15%
Suffolk 804 687,843 55,776 8.11% 427 383,448 34,463 8.99% 183 152,740 10,343 6.77% 194 151,655 10,970 7.23%
Westchester 438 353,489 25,430 7.19% 255 217,968 16,378 7.51% 108 87,569 5,676 6.48% 75 47,952 3,376 7.04%
Other * 7 3,322 245 7.38%
Total 3,988 3,291,283 258,915 7.87% 2,327 1,996,728 163,879 8.21% 807 650,623 44,825 6.89% 847 640,610 49,966 7.80%

Summary of Initial Idle Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data)
County All Vendors (including "Unknown") Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
# of
Facilities		 Total
Volume		 # of
Failed		 % Fail # of
Facilities		 Total
Volume		 # of
Failed		 % Fail # of
Facilities		 Total
Volume		 # of
Failed		 % Fail # of
Facilities		 Total
Volume		 # of
Failed		 % Fail
Bronx 273 24,070 542 2.25% 168 15,275 379 2.48% 44 3,422 53 1.55% 61 5,373 110 2.05%
Kings 569 51,884 939 1.81% 354 32,044 664 2.07% 63 7,577 110 1.45% 152 12,263 165 1.35%
Nassau 804 81,035 1,020 1.26% 452 43,755 711 1.62% 225 25,854 189 0.73% 127 11,426 120 1.05%
New York 146 26,305 298 1.13% 81 12,149 207 1.70% 28 9,030 27 0.30% 37 5,126 64 1.25%
Queens 682 75,338 1,358 1.80% 429 48,830 1,007 2.06% 108 12,518 104 0.83% 145 13,990 247 1.77%
Richmond 154 14,149 212 1.50% 79 8,139 154 1.89% 22 1,660 17 1.02% 53 4,350 41 0.94%
Rockland 133 24,451 375 1.53% 87 16,153 278 1.72% 27 5,149 37 0.72% 19 3,149 60 1.91%
Suffolk 809 87,685 1,285 1.47% 426 47,169 845 1.79% 186 25,245 192 0.76% 197 15,271 248 1.62%
Westchester 447 80,283 1,064 1.33% 257 49,627 773 1.56% 107 20,336 143 0.70% 83 10,320 148 1.43%
Other * 7 693 11 1.59%
Total 4,024 465,893 7,104 1.52% 2,333 273,141 5,018 1.84% 810 110,791 872 0.79% 874 81,268 1,203 1.48%

* Other includes New York Port Authority and Orange, Putnam, and undetermined counties



Appendix D
Summary of Initial Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
Table 1: Bronx County
(Based on 1/1/2002 to 12/31/2002 NYMA Data)
Model
Year		 Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested---
Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail
1978 11 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
1979 23 1 4.35% 6 1 16.67% 9 2 22.22%
1980 15 1 6.67% 5 0 0.00% 10 1 10.00%
1981 298 36 12.08% 8 0 0.00% 48 18 37.50% 3 0 0.00% 99 18 18.18% 4 0 0.00%
1982 407 52 12.78% 6 0 0.00% 66 18 27.27% 3 2 66.67% 97 7 7.22% 3 2 66.67%
1983 674 118 17.51% 11 2 18.18% 113 35 30.97% 4 0 0.00% 216 27 12.50% 9 2 22.22%
1984 1,281 201 15.69% 32 2 6.25% 197 66 33.50% 6 1 16.67% 345 38 11.01% 17 0 0.00%
1985 1,970 280 14.21% 55 5 9.09% 375 114 30.40% 5 2 40.00% 625 67 10.72% 28 4 14.29%
1986 3,145 426 13.55% 79 10 12.66% 578 165 28.55% 17 1 5.88% 995 86 8.64% 37 1 2.70%
1987 4,983 679 13.63% 104 10 9.62% 880 217 24.66% 16 0 0.00% 1,502 149 9.92% 57 2 3.51%
1988 6,352 872 13.73% 128 9 7.03% 1,131 273 24.14% 26 2 7.69% 1,989 214 10.76% 75 6 8.00%
1989 7,801 1,019 13.06% 199 15 7.54% 1,503 323 21.49% 35 3 8.57% 2,499 209 8.36% 117 6 5.13%
1990 10,752 1,359 12.64% 339 19 5.60% 1,832 346 18.89% 54 2 3.70% 3,502 296 8.45% 143 8 5.59%
1991 10,519 1,272 12.09% 538 17 3.16% 1,806 360 19.93% 80 7 8.75% 3,482 278 7.98% 210 8 3.81%
1992 12,122 1,355 11.18% 601 48 7.99% 2,157 337 15.62% 90 5 5.56% 3,831 270 7.05% 217 11 5.07%
1993 13,817 1,290 9.34% 859 28 3.26% 2,454 339 13.81% 153 4 2.61% 4,225 273 6.46% 325 14 4.31%
1994 13,414 993 7.40% 1,102 41 3.72% 2,505 178 7.11% 190 7 3.68% 4,234 208 4.91% 358 11 3.07%
1995 16,862 951 5.64% 1,190 46 3.87% 3,099 209 6.74% 203 4 1.97% 5,182 181 3.49% 409 16 3.91%
1996 13,790 1,018 7.38% 1,057 11 1.04% 2,825 196 6.94% 186 2 1.08% 4,265 257 6.03% 339 3 0.88%
1997 12,057 823 6.83% 1,658 31 1.87% 2,798 122 4.36% 359 5 1.39% 3,689 180 4.88% 521 3 0.58%
1998 11,423 555 4.86% 1,811 36 1.99% 2,711 63 2.32% 373 3 0.80% 3,628 137 3.78% 527 1 0.19%
1999 9,557 325 3.40% 1,826 20 1.10% 2,736 44 1.61% 471 1 0.21% 3,103 78 2.51% 623 4 0.64%
2000 9,479 280 2.95% 1,616 8 0.50% 3,151 37 1.17% 471 1 0.21% 3,259 66 2.03% 657 4 0.61%
2001 8,041 146 1.82% 2,007 19 0.95% 3,149 22 0.70% 666 0 0.00% 2,597 27 1.04% 678 1 0.15%
2002 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 1 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a
Total 168,744 14,050 8.33% 15,275 379 2.48% 36,114 3,482 9.64% 3,422 53 1.55% 53,365 3,066 5.75% 5,373 110 2.05%


Appendix D
Summary of Initial Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
Table 2: Kings County
(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data)
Model
Year		 Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested---
Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail
1978 25 3 12.00% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
1979 35 2 5.71% 1 0 0.00% 15 3 20.00%
1980 35 2 5.71% 1 0 0.00% 20 2 10.00%
1981 431 87 20.19% 12 1 8.33% 38 14 36.84% 3 0 0.00% 166 35 21.08% 10 1 10.00%
1982 590 110 18.64% 16 2 12.50% 66 23 34.85% 0 0 n/a 223 43 19.28% 19 0 0.00%
1983 1,024 214 20.90% 34 3 8.82% 123 37 30.08% 5 0 0.00% 378 85 22.49% 16 0 0.00%
1984 1,928 384 19.92% 55 8 14.55% 207 54 26.09% 9 1 11.11% 638 139 21.79% 28 3 10.71%
1985 3,089 607 19.65% 88 6 6.82% 361 88 24.38% 12 1 8.33% 1,172 226 19.28% 31 2 6.45%
1986 5,052 894 17.70% 124 8 6.45% 533 143 26.83% 22 3 13.64% 1,792 302 16.85% 41 0 0.00%
1987 7,981 1,312 16.44% 188 19 10.11% 838 177 21.12% 37 6 16.22% 2,918 492 16.86% 81 6 7.41%
1988 10,034 1,595 15.90% 275 18 6.55% 1,145 245 21.40% 61 8 13.11% 3,722 617 16.58% 123 6 4.88%
1989 13,120 1,905 14.52% 356 19 5.34% 1,528 281 18.39% 62 9 14.52% 5,022 682 13.58% 124 6 4.84%
1990 16,779 2,307 13.75% 545 32 5.87% 1,902 321 16.88% 101 11 10.89% 6,034 860 14.25% 235 10 4.26%
1991 16,565 2,169 13.09% 773 52 6.73% 1,896 340 17.93% 118 10 8.47% 6,044 784 12.97% 309 20 6.47%
1992 20,280 2,262 11.15% 1,016 59 5.81% 2,539 347 13.67% 157 8 5.10% 7,669 895 11.67% 325 14 4.31%
1993 22,833 2,151 9.42% 1,439 49 3.41% 2,606 365 14.01% 228 11 4.82% 8,606 873 10.14% 515 22 4.27%
1994 22,163 1,578 7.12% 1,856 62 3.34% 2,792 221 7.92% 304 8 2.63% 8,349 557 6.67% 641 18 2.81%
1995 26,449 1,384 5.23% 2,133 63 2.95% 3,354 215 6.41% 366 12 3.28% 10,493 526 5.01% 844 15 1.78%
1996 23,163 1,475 6.37% 2,061 49 2.38% 2,995 201 6.71% 348 6 1.72% 8,949 674 7.53% 780 5 0.64%
1997 22,703 1,313 5.78% 3,305 31 0.94% 3,081 160 5.19% 609 5 0.82% 9,181 579 6.31% 1,325 13 0.98%
1998 21,745 746 3.43% 3,713 25 0.67% 3,211 87 2.71% 778 5 0.64% 9,165 346 3.78% 1,396 9 0.64%
1999 20,505 546 2.66% 4,302 46 1.07% 3,283 53 1.61% 1,050 3 0.29% 8,582 227 2.65% 1,667 5 0.30%
2000 21,185 428 2.02% 4,727 46 0.97% 3,787 47 1.24% 1,572 2 0.13% 9,457 170 1.80% 1,714 4 0.23%
2001 17,126 201 1.17% 4,930 59 1.20% 3,541 26 0.73% 1,733 1 0.06% 7,885 68 0.86% 2,004 1 0.05%
2002 3 0 0.00% 1 0 0.00% 1 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a 1 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a
Total 294,748 23,668 8.03% 32,044 664 2.07% 39,827 3,445 8.65% 7,577 110 1.45% 116,446 9,180 7.88% 12,263 165 1.35%


Appendix D
Summary of Initial Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
Table 3: Nassau County
(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data
Model
Year		 Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested---
Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail
1978 23 3 13.04% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
1979 46 5 10.87% 10 2 20.00% 11 2 18.18%
1980 43 8 18.60% 21 4 19.05% 7 2 28.57%
1981 581 175 30.12% 31 2 6.45% 198 61 30.81% 12 1 8.33% 111 25 22.52% 6 0 0.00%
1982 741 222 29.96% 36 4 11.11% 284 103 36.27% 16 5 31.25% 158 47 29.75% 9 2 22.22%
1983 1,316 439 33.36% 54 8 14.81% 512 167 32.62% 28 3 10.71% 295 90 30.51% 14 2 14.29%
1984 2,345 759 32.37% 97 17 17.53% 981 304 30.99% 33 2 6.06% 530 157 29.62% 30 3 10.00%
1985 3,878 1,172 30.22% 138 21 15.22% 1,562 433 27.72% 46 12 26.09% 907 263 29.00% 19 2 10.53%
1986 6,018 1,630 27.09% 192 17 8.85% 2,478 609 24.58% 80 10 12.50% 1,352 388 28.70% 41 4 9.76%
1987 9,334 2,171 23.26% 228 21 9.21% 3,623 797 22.00% 82 5 6.10% 2,005 494 24.64% 60 3 5.00%
1988 11,388 2,491 21.87% 257 23 8.95% 4,475 943 21.07% 103 11 10.68% 2,516 596 23.69% 68 4 5.88%
1989 14,726 2,725 18.50% 342 28 8.19% 5,719 1,006 17.59% 152 17 11.18% 3,150 664 21.08% 85 9 10.59%
1990 16,354 2,802 17.13% 467 37 7.92% 6,660 1,032 15.50% 188 6 3.19% 3,696 668 18.07% 136 10 7.35%
1991 16,832 2,573 15.29% 666 37 5.56% 6,914 983 14.22% 299 13 4.35% 3,788 626 16.53% 143 8 5.59%
1992 18,465 2,421 13.11% 797 38 4.77% 7,977 996 12.49% 378 13 3.44% 4,091 606 14.81% 196 6 3.06%
1993 21,545 2,253 10.46% 1,425 32 2.25% 9,280 913 9.84% 656 17 2.59% 5,042 609 12.08% 344 6 1.74%
1994 22,032 1,611 7.31% 1,865 50 2.68% 10,075 544 5.40% 964 21 2.18% 5,114 363 7.10% 447 7 1.57%
1995 26,520 1,392 5.25% 2,207 42 1.90% 12,679 509 4.01% 1,067 18 1.69% 6,273 301 4.80% 585 19 3.25%
1996 23,695 1,244 5.25% 2,096 23 1.10% 11,605 490 4.22% 1,151 5 0.43% 5,680 355 6.25% 543 1 0.18%
1997 25,726 1,010 3.93% 3,934 40 1.02% 13,296 341 2.56% 2,222 10 0.45% 6,368 320 5.03% 1,027 8 0.78%
1998 27,715 615 2.22% 4,481 50 1.12% 15,376 232 1.51% 2,627 5 0.19% 6,871 203 2.95% 1,121 9 0.80%
1999 28,986 532 1.84% 5,837 54 0.93% 17,152 198 1.15% 3,607 4 0.11% 7,252 144 1.99% 1,654 4 0.24%
2000 35,546 388 1.09% 7,559 61 0.81% 23,355 153 0.66% 4,729 1 0.02% 9,082 102 1.12% 2,157 5 0.23%
2001 36,450 202 0.55% 10,932 90 0.82% 26,467 87 0.33% 7,381 4 0.05% 9,678 44 0.45% 2,723 4 0.15%
2002 4 0 0.00% 2 0 0.00% 4 1 25.00% 2 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
Total 350,197 28,827 8.23% 43,755 711 1.62% 180,672 10,902 6.03% 25,854 189 0.73% 83,959 7,065 8.41% 11,426 120 1.05%


Appendix D
Summary of Initial Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
Table 4: New York County
(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data)
Model
Year		 Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested---
Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail
1978 6 2 33.33% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
1979 9 4 44.44% 6 1 16.67% 4 0 0.00%
1980 13 2 15.38% 4 0 0.00% 5 1 20.00%
1981 82 24 29.27% 2 0 0.00% 29 13 44.83% 1 0 0.00% 24 6 25.00% 2 1 50.00%
1982 101 16 15.84% 5 0 0.00% 39 11 28.21% 0 0 n/a 47 17 36.17% 1 0 0.00%
1983 195 41 21.03% 12 1 8.33% 57 12 21.05% 4 0 0.00% 57 24 42.11% 4 2 50.00%
1984 321 78 24.30% 23 0 0.00% 111 37 33.33% 3 1 33.33% 138 50 36.23% 6 0 0.00%
1985 524 121 23.09% 34 4 11.76% 172 55 31.98% 8 1 12.50% 191 54 28.27% 12 1 8.33%
1986 783 134 17.11% 41 3 7.32% 246 65 26.42% 11 0 0.00% 309 85 27.51% 19 4 21.05%
1987 1,292 218 16.87% 84 4 4.76% 390 91 23.33% 13 1 7.69% 454 104 22.91% 19 2 10.53%
1988 1,628 215 13.21% 110 14 12.73% 497 109 21.93% 27 0 0.00% 550 131 23.82% 35 3 8.57%
1989 2,018 257 12.74% 104 6 5.77% 622 107 17.20% 37 0 0.00% 763 155 20.31% 54 4 7.41%
1990 2,886 374 12.96% 191 7 3.66% 751 134 17.84% 38 3 7.89% 909 191 21.01% 68 6 8.82%
1991 2,837 340 11.98% 285 10 3.51% 853 114 13.36% 84 1 1.19% 978 166 16.97% 111 6 5.41%
1992 3,277 331 10.10% 321 23 7.17% 951 126 13.25% 98 2 2.04% 1,118 173 15.47% 100 6 6.00%
1993 3,630 314 8.65% 436 13 2.98% 1,133 136 12.00% 167 3 1.80% 1,350 172 12.74% 169 3 1.78%
1994 3,668 244 6.65% 542 11 2.03% 1,246 90 7.22% 211 2 0.95% 1,386 127 9.16% 186 3 1.61%
1995 4,926 218 4.43% 748 19 2.54% 1,710 91 5.32% 305 3 0.98% 1,718 128 7.45% 263 4 1.52%
1996 4,159 282 6.78% 726 9 1.24% 1,517 96 6.33% 349 1 0.29% 1,517 147 9.69% 272 4 1.47%
1997 4,064 336 8.27% 1,090 14 1.28% 1,912 94 4.92% 604 2 0.33% 1,638 138 8.42% 402 1 0.25%
1998 4,127 199 4.82% 1,441 13 0.90% 2,287 65 2.84% 950 2 0.21% 1,746 86 4.93% 592 2 0.34%
1999 4,067 158 3.88% 1,579 15 0.95% 3,024 63 2.08% 1,225 2 0.16% 1,744 70 4.01% 777 7 0.90%
2000 4,301 195 4.53% 1,825 19 1.04% 4,517 82 1.82% 1,993 0 0.00% 2,125 58 2.73% 799 1 0.13%
2001 4,055 98 2.42% 2,522 14 0.56% 4,587 39 0.85% 2,892 2 0.07% 2,119 39 1.84% 1,226 3 0.24%
2002 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 3 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
Total 52,941 4,193 7.92% 12,149 207 1.70% 26,654 1,630 6.12% 9,030 27 0.30% 20,881 2,121 10.16% 5,126 64 1.25%


Appendix D
Summary of Initial Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
Table 5: Queens County
(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data)
Model
Year		 Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested---
Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail
1978 28 5 17.86% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
1979 42 4 9.52% 14 2 14.29% 13 3 23.08%
1980 49 6 12.24% 15 0 0.00% 13 0 0.00%
1981 590 146 24.75% 30 2 6.67% 115 20 17.39% 10 4 40.00% 158 33 20.89% 13 1 7.69%
1982 737 173 23.47% 30 2 6.67% 147 37 25.17% 5 1 20.00% 206 52 25.24% 7 1 14.29%
1983 1,276 309 24.22% 47 7 14.89% 275 64 23.27% 4 0 0.00% 388 89 22.94% 22 2 9.09%
1984 2,396 522 21.79% 98 8 8.16% 567 141 24.87% 24 3 12.50% 667 169 25.34% 31 3 9.68%
1985 3,862 816 21.13% 144 8 5.56% 835 174 20.84% 23 3 13.04% 1,095 255 23.29% 49 7 14.29%
1986 6,132 1,153 18.80% 206 20 9.71% 1,292 259 20.05% 36 1 2.78% 1,810 368 20.33% 88 8 9.09%
1987 9,431 1,680 17.81% 307 21 6.84% 1,976 361 18.27% 43 5 11.63% 2,612 524 20.06% 94 9 9.57%
1988 12,202 2,122 17.39% 396 27 6.82% 2,580 449 17.40% 72 2 2.78% 3,405 643 18.88% 124 3 2.42%
1989 15,804 2,323 14.70% 473 37 7.82% 3,258 513 15.75% 86 6 6.98% 4,441 679 15.29% 185 7 3.78%
1990 19,407 2,886 14.87% 708 41 5.79% 4,066 660 16.23% 120 1 0.83% 5,470 853 15.59% 258 11 4.26%
1991 19,209 2,634 13.71% 1,110 73 6.58% 4,091 633 15.47% 199 4 2.01% 5,588 825 14.76% 338 17 5.03%
1992 22,195 2,640 11.89% 1,302 79 6.07% 4,878 661 13.55% 230 8 3.48% 6,288 863 13.72% 401 21 5.24%
1993 25,215 2,557 10.14% 2,104 69 3.28% 5,678 732 12.89% 413 12 2.91% 7,231 852 11.78% 558 30 5.38%
1994 25,348 1,889 7.45% 2,548 83 3.26% 6,046 444 7.34% 509 11 2.16% 7,428 564 7.59% 749 39 5.21%
1995 31,851 1,811 5.69% 3,200 94 2.94% 7,662 417 5.44% 606 12 1.98% 9,181 524 5.71% 878 27 3.08%
1996 28,134 2,083 7.40% 2,973 51 1.72% 7,099 471 6.63% 633 5 0.79% 8,182 702 8.58% 846 10 1.18%
1997 28,916 1,937 6.70% 4,739 64 1.35% 7,381 408 5.53% 1,103 6 0.54% 8,310 562 6.76% 1,395 21 1.51%
1998 28,789 1,155 4.01% 5,656 74 1.31% 7,705 229 2.97% 1,315 9 0.68% 8,830 403 4.56% 1,687 11 0.65%
1999 28,382 909 3.20% 6,749 77 1.14% 7,927 149 1.88% 1,770 4 0.23% 8,737 288 3.30% 1,929 8 0.41%
2000 32,807 720 2.19% 8,276 84 1.01% 10,616 151 1.42% 3,021 4 0.13% 9,810 187 1.91% 1,942 5 0.26%
2001 25,314 394 1.56% 7,615 71 0.93% 7,994 59 0.74% 2,267 1 0.04% 8,794 120 1.36% 2,368 3 0.13%
2002 3 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 3 0 0.00% 2 0 0.00%
Total 368,000 30,859 8.39% 48,830 1,007 2.06% 92,188 7,032 7.63% 12,518 104 0.83% 108,634 9,555 8.80% 13,990 247 1.77%


Appendix D
Summary of Initial Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
Table 6: Richmond County
(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data)
Model
Year		 Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested---
Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail
1978 9 3 33.33% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
1979 8 1 12.50% 6 1 16.67% 6 1 16.67%
1980 13 2 15.38% 2 0 0.00% 4 2 50.00%
1981 133 26 19.55% 2 0 0.00% 30 8 26.67% 1 0 0.00% 56 17 30.36% 2 0 0.00%
1982 162 18 11.11% 5 0 0.00% 25 8 32.00% 0 0 n/a 54 16 29.63% 1 0 0.00%
1983 270 46 17.04% 9 2 22.22% 49 13 26.53% 2 1 50.00% 111 30 27.03% 4 0 0.00%
1984 494 101 20.45% 20 1 5.00% 86 27 31.40% 2 0 0.00% 262 60 22.90% 4 0 0.00%
1985 846 155 18.32% 34 5 14.71% 159 38 23.90% 4 1 25.00% 398 102 25.63% 5 0 0.00%
1986 1,250 201 16.08% 37 6 16.22% 253 48 18.97% 4 0 0.00% 684 137 20.03% 14 1 7.14%
1987 1,956 267 13.65% 46 2 4.35% 383 81 21.15% 10 1 10.00% 980 187 19.08% 13 3 23.08%
1988 2,634 382 14.50% 70 1 1.43% 486 90 18.52% 11 2 18.18% 1,238 233 18.82% 23 1 4.35%
1989 3,312 397 11.99% 84 7 8.33% 690 115 16.67% 9 0 0.00% 1,641 289 17.61% 23 1 4.35%
1990 3,724 458 12.30% 88 7 7.95% 735 130 17.69% 13 2 15.38% 1,914 304 15.88% 43 3 6.98%
1991 3,706 432 11.66% 117 6 5.13% 747 105 14.06% 24 1 4.17% 1,882 288 15.30% 69 4 5.80%
1992 4,257 445 10.45% 156 11 7.05% 898 110 12.25% 21 1 4.76% 2,403 343 14.27% 84 2 2.38%
1993 5,204 425 8.17% 269 12 4.46% 1,050 116 11.05% 50 1 2.00% 2,689 349 12.98% 146 6 4.11%
1994 5,054 303 6.00% 343 11 3.21% 1,106 68 6.15% 67 2 2.99% 2,914 225 7.72% 176 4 2.27%
1995 6,078 288 4.74% 369 14 3.79% 1,298 62 4.78% 67 1 1.49% 3,491 186 5.33% 193 3 1.55%
1996 5,361 301 5.61% 374 5 1.34% 1,195 56 4.69% 71 0 0.00% 3,002 253 8.43% 242 2 0.83%
1997 5,702 260 4.56% 731 12 1.64% 1,304 44 3.37% 150 0 0.00% 3,396 181 5.33% 422 2 0.47%
1998 6,068 169 2.79% 822 12 1.46% 1,381 13 0.94% 191 1 0.52% 3,568 135 3.78% 464 3 0.65%
1999 6,124 137 2.24% 1,114 12 1.08% 1,458 20 1.37% 206 1 0.49% 3,683 85 2.31% 555 0 0.00%
2000 8,199 154 1.88% 1,322 9 0.68% 1,869 11 0.59% 283 0 0.00% 4,756 80 1.68% 693 1 0.14%
2001 9,091 103 1.13% 2,097 13 0.62% 2,184 6 0.27% 466 1 0.21% 5,376 56 1.04% 1,164 2 0.17%
2002 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
Total 79,625 5,068 6.36% 8,139 154 1.89% 17,386 1,169 6.72% 1,660 17 1.02% 44,498 3,556 7.99% 4,350 41 0.94%


Appendix D
Summary of Initial Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
Table 7: Rockland County
(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data)
Model
Year		 Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested---
Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail
1978 11 1 9.09% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
1979 16 1 6.25% 1 1 100.00% 3 0 0.00%
1980 9 1 11.11% 1 1 100.00% 0 0 n/a
1981 74 26 35.14% 10 2 20.00% 19 9 47.37% 2 1 50.00% 9 2 22.22% 4 0 0.00%
1982 91 29 31.87% 15 3 20.00% 20 9 45.00% 5 0 0.00% 25 11 44.00% 7 3 42.86%
1983 174 46 26.44% 20 4 20.00% 24 9 37.50% 6 0 0.00% 31 9 29.03% 7 0 0.00%
1984 311 100 32.15% 36 3 8.33% 41 15 36.59% 8 2 25.00% 65 20 30.77% 7 0 0.00%
1985 552 151 27.36% 50 5 10.00% 76 25 32.89% 14 0 0.00% 100 33 33.00% 14 2 14.29%
1986 907 221 24.37% 110 9 8.18% 144 46 31.94% 8 0 0.00% 154 51 33.12% 17 2 11.76%
1987 1,528 323 21.14% 102 6 5.88% 229 64 27.95% 24 3 12.50% 234 60 25.64% 31 4 12.90%
1988 1,964 440 22.40% 151 10 6.62% 287 66 23.00% 43 5 11.63% 339 96 28.32% 34 1 2.94%
1989 2,614 520 19.89% 208 12 5.77% 386 109 28.24% 44 0 0.00% 410 81 19.76% 45 3 6.67%
1990 3,401 686 20.17% 249 14 5.62% 528 127 24.05% 72 2 2.78% 508 95 18.70% 45 3 6.67%
1991 3,608 646 17.90% 307 20 6.51% 528 104 19.70% 74 1 1.35% 525 94 17.90% 63 3 4.76%
1992 4,248 617 14.52% 331 17 5.14% 679 122 17.97% 87 2 2.30% 631 100 15.85% 54 3 5.56%
1993 5,179 613 11.84% 528 18 3.41% 882 116 13.15% 143 3 2.10% 763 96 12.58% 107 5 4.67%
1994 5,316 432 8.13% 735 18 2.45% 1,023 74 7.23% 204 1 0.49% 843 59 7.00% 137 2 1.46%
1995 6,537 369 5.64% 957 25 2.61% 1,247 54 4.33% 237 3 1.27% 1,061 60 5.66% 198 11 5.56%
1996 5,905 354 5.99% 896 6 0.67% 1,253 66 5.27% 269 2 0.74% 970 84 8.66% 165 6 3.64%
1997 6,380 293 4.59% 1,327 14 1.06% 1,402 57 4.07% 404 3 0.74% 1,052 56 5.32% 262 2 0.76%
1998 6,761 160 2.37% 1,669 14 0.84% 1,580 31 1.96% 598 2 0.33% 1,101 27 2.45% 326 5 1.53%
1999 7,309 145 1.98% 2,103 23 1.09% 1,959 25 1.28% 696 2 0.29% 1,223 21 1.72% 371 3 0.81%
2000 9,037 121 1.34% 2,647 17 0.64% 2,428 15 0.62% 923 3 0.33% 1,535 17 1.11% 477 1 0.21%
2001 9,161 81 0.88% 3,666 35 0.95% 2,737 3 0.11% 1,286 0 0.00% 1,641 5 0.30% 775 1 0.13%
2002 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 1 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
Total 81,057 6,373 7.86% 16,153 278 1.72% 17,473 1,146 6.56% 5,149 37 0.72% 13,220 1,077 8.15% 3,149 60 1.91%


Appendix D
Summary of Initial Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
Table 8: Suffolk County
(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data)
Model
Year		 Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested---
Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail
1978 44 12 27.27% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
1979 74 16 21.62% 28 7 25.00% 32 7 21.88%
1980 60 10 16.67% 16 3 18.75% 22 1 4.55%
1981 651 230 35.33% 43 4 9.30% 187 65 34.76% 18 2 11.11% 265 60 22.64% 27 4 14.81%
1982 851 253 29.73% 59 13 22.03% 273 98 35.90% 28 4 14.29% 312 71 22.76% 22 3 13.64%
1983 1,560 548 35.13% 82 11 13.41% 428 138 32.24% 29 2 6.90% 548 120 21.90% 34 6 17.65%
1984 2,863 985 34.40% 137 20 14.60% 871 275 31.57% 60 3 5.00% 1,070 258 24.11% 54 9 16.67%
1985 4,528 1,379 30.45% 214 30 14.02% 1,316 406 30.85% 81 10 12.35% 1,688 399 23.64% 96 13 13.54%
1986 7,151 1,978 27.66% 322 42 13.04% 2,084 557 26.73% 127 22 17.32% 2,800 553 19.75% 123 10 8.13%
1987 10,255 2,649 25.83% 329 31 9.42% 3,075 738 24.00% 143 10 6.99% 4,121 737 17.88% 131 19 14.50%
1988 12,949 3,233 24.97% 356 34 9.55% 3,834 887 23.14% 195 13 6.67% 5,131 962 18.75% 163 17 10.43%
1989 15,642 3,198 20.44% 424 42 9.91% 4,866 937 19.26% 174 7 4.02% 6,431 973 15.13% 214 12 5.61%
1990 17,129 3,242 18.93% 550 38 6.91% 5,465 1,008 18.44% 226 16 7.08% 7,193 1,068 14.85% 233 13 5.58%
1991 17,533 2,824 16.11% 731 54 7.39% 5,399 875 16.21% 286 16 5.59% 7,475 997 13.34% 263 15 5.70%
1992 19,252 2,838 14.74% 869 41 4.72% 6,153 817 13.28% 364 8 2.20% 8,090 936 11.57% 347 17 4.90%
1993 23,499 2,684 11.42% 1,601 51 3.19% 7,510 905 12.05% 641 15 2.34% 9,835 1,007 10.24% 543 12 2.21%
1994 24,723 2,001 8.09% 2,106 43 2.04% 8,367 568 6.79% 801 10 1.25% 10,348 635 6.14% 756 16 2.12%
1995 30,176 1,771 5.87% 2,609 59 2.26% 10,454 528 5.05% 1,055 15 1.42% 12,389 558 4.50% 941 22 2.34%
1996 26,146 1,527 5.84% 2,493 27 1.08% 9,866 499 5.06% 1,132 3 0.27% 10,613 567 5.34% 946 14 1.48%
1997 28,302 1,166 4.12% 4,411 29 0.66% 11,334 348 3.07% 2,172 5 0.23% 11,217 432 3.85% 1,659 12 0.72%
1998 30,301 736 2.43% 4,921 48 0.98% 13,300 253 1.90% 2,615 4 0.15% 12,010 274 2.28% 1,611 9 0.56%
1999 33,264 607 1.82% 6,466 45 0.70% 15,189 195 1.28% 3,639 9 0.25% 12,986 198 1.52% 2,141 9 0.42%
2000 38,674 412 1.07% 7,751 65 0.84% 20,790 164 0.79% 4,664 4 0.09% 13,754 107 0.78% 2,108 7 0.33%
2001 37,997 202 0.53% 10,514 80 0.76% 21,971 82 0.37% 6,751 4 0.06% 13,379 58 0.43% 2,805 1 0.04%
2002 2 0 0.00% 3 0 0.00% 8 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
Total 383,448 34,463 8.99% 47,169 845 1.79% 152,740 10,343 6.77% 25,245 192 0.76% 151,655 10,970 7.23% 15,271 248 1.62%


Appendix D
Summary of Initial Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
Table 9: Westchester County
(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data)
Model
Year		 Vendor=ESP Vendor=SPX Vendor=SUN
---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested--- ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested---
Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail
1978 21 7 33.33% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
1979 25 6 24.00% 9 2 22.22% 7 1 14.29%
1980 27 5 18.52% 9 2 22.22% 9 0 0.00%
1981 297 95 31.99% 32 8 25.00% 92 27 29.35% 9 1 11.11% 79 24 30.38% 7 0 0.00%
1982 387 130 33.59% 42 9 21.43% 133 38 28.57% 8 2 25.00% 102 29 28.43% 11 0 0.00%
1983 599 180 30.05% 69 10 14.49% 243 66 27.16% 17 1 5.88% 183 42 22.95% 12 1 8.33%
1984 1,196 366 30.60% 112 16 14.29% 453 119 26.27% 31 2 6.45% 326 80 24.54% 22 2 9.09%
1985 1,931 511 26.46% 143 17 11.89% 761 189 24.84% 35 2 5.71% 480 105 21.88% 33 3 9.09%
1986 3,105 758 24.41% 249 28 11.24% 1,160 273 23.53% 61 6 9.84% 753 152 20.19% 55 7 12.73%
1987 4,744 995 20.97% 349 37 10.60% 1,835 406 22.13% 90 2 2.22% 1,163 262 22.53% 77 5 6.49%
1988 6,182 1,331 21.53% 401 24 5.99% 2,229 453 20.32% 108 11 10.19% 1,414 270 19.09% 108 7 6.48%
1989 7,691 1,336 17.37% 515 27 5.24% 2,888 482 16.69% 135 9 6.67% 1,767 300 16.98% 118 12 10.17%
1990 9,413 1,664 17.68% 705 37 5.25% 3,426 551 16.08% 193 13 6.74% 2,082 310 14.89% 128 6 4.69%
1991 9,810 1,479 15.08% 764 37 4.84% 3,663 553 15.10% 252 13 5.16% 2,277 307 13.48% 202 8 3.96%
1992 11,166 1,419 12.71% 991 43 4.34% 4,106 531 12.93% 294 12 4.08% 2,661 314 11.80% 205 11 5.37%
1993 12,971 1,382 10.65% 1,490 47 3.15% 4,847 539 11.12% 499 13 2.61% 2,898 273 9.42% 327 16 4.89%
1994 14,173 1,008 7.11% 1,897 53 2.79% 5,429 336 6.19% 565 14 2.48% 3,255 182 5.59% 396 13 3.28%
1995 17,148 902 5.26% 2,533 45 1.78% 6,642 306 4.61% 907 9 0.99% 3,816 163 4.27% 588 14 2.38%
1996 15,329 868 5.66% 2,573 22 0.86% 5,802 268 4.62% 905 1 0.11% 3,389 188 5.55% 589 5 0.85%
1997 16,659 688 4.13% 4,303 41 0.95% 6,531 192 2.94% 1,758 7 0.40% 3,621 139 3.84% 940 4 0.43%
1998 18,018 458 2.54% 5,381 38 0.71% 7,177 128 1.78% 2,297 9 0.39% 3,969 106 2.67% 1,110 11 0.99%
1999 19,031 352 1.85% 6,428 53 0.82% 7,990 103 1.29% 2,757 8 0.29% 4,070 69 1.70% 1,334 8 0.60%
2000 23,742 292 1.23% 7,901 55 0.70% 10,571 77 0.73% 3,933 3 0.08% 4,636 37 0.80% 1,602 3 0.19%
2001 24,373 164 0.67% 12,676 108 0.85% 11,589 39 0.34% 5,464 1 0.02% 5,011 24 0.48% 2,440 11 0.45%
2002 3 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a 2 0 0.00% 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
Total 217,968 16,378 7.51% 49,627 773 1.56% 87,569 5,676 6.48% 20,336 143 0.70% 47,952 3,376 7.04% 10,320 148 1.43%


Appendix D
Summary of Initial Test Volume and Initial Failure Rates By County and Vendor
Table 10: County Other* - All Vendors(Based on 1/1/2003 to 12/31/2003 NYMA Data)
Model
Year		 ---TransientTested--- ---IdleTested---
Volume Failed % Fail Volume Failed % Fail
1978 0 0 n/a
1979 0 0 n/a
1980 0 0 n/a
1981 2 2 100.00% 0 0 n/a
1982 4 2 50.00% 0 0 n/a
1983 5 1 20.00% 1 0 0.00%
1984 12 3 25.00% 1 0 0.00%
1985 22 11 50.00% 4 0 0.00%
1986 42 21 50.00% 3 1 33.33%
1987 47 10 21.28% 6 0 0.00%
1988 61 19 31.15% 5 1 20.00%
1989 94 26 27.66% 6 0 0.00%
1990 105 24 22.86% 7 1 14.29%
1991 89 14 15.73% 12 0 0.00%
1992 123 21 17.07% 14 0 0.00%
1993 149 15 10.07% 11 0 0.00%
1994 213 20 9.39% 26 5 19.23%
1995 263 10 3.80% 42 0 0.00%
1996 216 11 5.09% 44 0 0.00%
1997 284 11 3.87% 69 1 1.45%
1998 326 13 3.99% 81 2 2.47%
1999 354 4 1.13% 99 0 0.00%
2000 469 3 0.64% 111 0 0.00%
2001 442 4 0.90% 151 0 0.00%
2002 0 0 n/a 0 0 n/a
Total 3,322 245 7.38% 693 11 1.59%

* "Other" includes New York Port Authority and Orange, Putnam, and undetermined counties.

Download a copy of the Lotus 1-2-3 file containing all report Appendices.