Similarities And Differences Among New York's Trout
| Species | Description | Habitat | Reproduction | Feeding | Fishing Information | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brook Trout | 6-10" long in streams; 10-12" in ponds Up to 8 lbs. Square tail Olive green with lighter wavy markings above, yellow spots and some red spots on side White line along front edge of lower fins |
Cold lakes, ponds and streams Often found in very small brooks |
Spawns in fall (mid Oct-early Dec) Female digs shallow nest (redd) on gravel beds in spring-fed streams |
Usually eats insects | Prized gamefish Relative east to catch Use flies, small minnows or worms |
New York State Fish Well-known for beauty and high catchability New York native |
| Lake Trout | 15-34 " long Up to 30 lbs. Forked tail Silvery to dark gray above, white below Light yellowish spots on sides, tail and dorsal fin |
Deep, cool, well-oxygenated lakes | Spawns in fall (late Oct-Nov) Scatters eggs over shallow, rocky reefs No nest is built |
Adult mainly eat fish such as smelt, alewives, sculpins and minnows Young eat insects and crustaceans |
In early spring troll near the surface with artificial lures or natural fish In summer troll deep with downriggers or wire line and use flashy lures |
New York native Prized due to large size and strength Taste somewhat inferior to other trout |
| Brown Trout | 8-20" long in Inland waters 20-32" long in Great Lakes Up to 30 lbs. Silvery to olive green above with dark brown or black spots (sometimes a few red or orange) on sides, dorsal and adipose fins Occasionally several spots on tail |
Cool streams and lakes Some sea-run strains |
Spawns in fall (late Oct-Dec) Female digs shallow nest on gravel areas of clear, cold streams |
Small brown trout mainly eat insects Large brown trout eat fish such as minnows, smelt and alewives |
Relatively difficult to catch Cast or troll flies, artificial lures, worms and minnows |
Introduced from Europe in the 1880's Tolerate warmer water than either brook or lake trout Withstands heavy fishing pressure better than other trout |
| Rainbow Trout | 8-20" long in Inland waters 20-34" long in Great Lakes Up to 25 lbs. Silvery to olive or blue/green above with numerous black spots on head, sides, dorsal fin, adipose fin and tail May have pink-red banc along side |
Usually cool lakes and larger streams | Spawns late winter-spring (Jan-May) Female builds nest on gravelly areas of clear, cold streams |
Small rainbows mainly eat insects Large rainbows eat fish such as minnows, smelt and alewives |
Fairly easy to catch Cast or troll flies, artificial lures, worms and minnows Prized sportfish. Well-known for its leaping and fighting abilities when hooked |
Introduced from the Pacific Coast Sea-run (or lake-run) variety are called steelhead Steelhead are present only in Great Lakes, Lake Champlain and their tributaries |




